Subgenres/Sci-Fi/Alternate History

Alternate History

Alternate history asks what if: a battle lost, an invention delayed, a leader never born. The story follows that single change through to a different present.

Parent genre: Sci-FiModern form from the 1930s, boomed from the 1990s3,274 books classified in Saga

Where alternate history came from

Historians have always played the game; the Roman historian Livy wondered what would have happened if Alexander the Great had turned west against Rome. In fiction, L. Sprague de Camp's Lest Darkness Fall (1939) sent a modern archaeologist back to sixth-century Rome to prevent the Dark Ages, and Ward Moore's Bring the Jubilee (1953) imagined a Confederate victory in the American Civil War.

Philip K. Dick's The Man in the High Castle (1962), set in an America divided between Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan, won the Hugo Award and became the form's best-known novel. Keith Roberts' Pavane (1968) imagined a Catholic England where the Reformation never happened.

In the 1990s the form boomed. Harry Turtledove, sometimes called the master of alternate history, sent AK-47s back to the Confederacy in The Guns of the South (1992). Robert Harris' Fatherland (1992) was a detective story in a victorious Nazi Germany, Philip Roth's The Plot Against America (2004) put Charles Lindbergh in the White House, and Michael Chabon's The Yiddish Policemen's Union (2007) imagined a Jewish homeland in Alaska.

What separates it from neighbouring subgenres

Alternate history is defined by its premise: a single point where history went differently, followed carefully to its consequences. It's easy to confuse with stories that play with the past in other ways.

Time Travel

Time travel is usually about the act of changing history. Alternate history starts after the change and explores the world that resulted, often with no time travellers at all.

Historical Fantasy

Historical fantasy keeps the record and adds magic beneath it. Alternate history changes the record and usually keeps the world otherwise realistic.

Steampunk

Many steampunk stories are alternate histories built around one technology. Steampunk centres the aesthetic of the machines; alternate history centres the consequences.

Dystopian

A large share of alternate histories imagine the Axis winning the Second World War, which makes them dystopias too.

Alternate history is the most rigorous kind of fantasy: change one thing, and account for everything else.

How it reads

Expect a recognisable world bent out of shape: familiar cities with different flags, real historical figures in unfamiliar roles. Much of the pleasure is in detail, and readers who know the history will spot changes and jokes everywhere. The point of divergence is often revealed gradually.

Many alternate histories are thrillers or detective stories, using the genre plot to explore the world. Others are sprawling multi-volume chronicles that follow the change across decades.



Frequently asked

What's the difference between alternate history and time travel?+

Time travel stories usually focus on the act of changing the past. Alternate history begins after a change, which may not involve time travel at all, and explores the world that resulted.

Where should a new reader start?+

The Man in the High Castle is the classic. Fatherland is a faster, more conventional thriller in a similar world.

Why do so many alternate histories involve the Second World War?+

It's the twentieth century's biggest turning point, and imagining a different outcome raises the starkest questions. The American Civil War is the other most common point of divergence.

Is there an award for alternate history?+

Yes. The Sidewise Awards for Alternate History have been given since 1995, named after Murray Leinster's story 'Sidewise in Time'.

Is alternate history science fiction?+

It's usually shelved there, since it's speculative and often rigorous about cause and effect. Some alternate histories are also shelved as historical fiction or thrillers.


Keep track of the long ones

Saga Reads follows your place across sprawling series and universes, remembers reading order, and asks Sage what to read next. Free to use.